Fantasy Book Feedback Needed
Budget / Salary$50–65
TypeFreelance project
LocationRemote
Posted5 hours ago
I'm seeking detailed feedback on my fantasy novel featuring dragons, trolls, and elves, and medieval life centered around a daring rescue attempt. It is about 60,000 words and written for teens and adults.
Please read it yourself. Your feedback must be written by you, not generated by AI. Please keep the manuscript private and do not upload it to any AI tool.
I want an honest reaction on four things.
First, characters and plot: are they predictable or unexpected? Please give specific examples of where and why.
Second, did you want to finish it? If not, where did you stop, and why? If you lose interest, please name the chapter and the passage where it happened and explain what made you stop. If you couldn't put it down, I want to know that too.
Third, if you have time, tell me whether the writing is engaging, whether the fantasy world feels believable and vivid, and whether the action and suspense scenes flow smoothly.
Fourth, after reading, do you want the sequel?
Please send your feedback as comments in the document, with a short summary at the end.
If you bid on this project, I will reply in your Freelancer chat, not here. Before I award anyone, I'll send a short set of questions about your reading tastes, and I'd like your answers there, in your own words. If I don't hear back, I'll assume you're not interested, and that's perfectly fine. I would rather we both find that out early than waste each other's time. Please also know that I use AI assistance in my writing, and I explain how in the chat before anything is sent.
Please read it yourself. Your feedback must be written by you, not generated by AI. Please keep the manuscript private and do not upload it to any AI tool.
I want an honest reaction on four things.
First, characters and plot: are they predictable or unexpected? Please give specific examples of where and why.
Second, did you want to finish it? If not, where did you stop, and why? If you lose interest, please name the chapter and the passage where it happened and explain what made you stop. If you couldn't put it down, I want to know that too.
Third, if you have time, tell me whether the writing is engaging, whether the fantasy world feels believable and vivid, and whether the action and suspense scenes flow smoothly.
Fourth, after reading, do you want the sequel?
Please send your feedback as comments in the document, with a short summary at the end.
If you bid on this project, I will reply in your Freelancer chat, not here. Before I award anyone, I'll send a short set of questions about your reading tastes, and I'd like your answers there, in your own words. If I don't hear back, I'll assume you're not interested, and that's perfectly fine. I would rather we both find that out early than waste each other's time. Please also know that I use AI assistance in my writing, and I explain how in the chat before anything is sent.
Apply on Freelancer →
Project sourced from Freelancer.com. Applications happen directly on the original platform — we never collect your data.